4.9 Average on Google
Rheumatoid Arthritis Disability Claims Attorney in New York
Key Takeaways
- Proving disability for arthritis can be difficult because symptoms such as pain and stiffness often fluctuate from day to day. Consistent and detailed medical records are crucial.
- Doctors’ reports, imaging results, and notes about how arthritis affects your ability to work all play a major role in getting long-term disability benefits.
- Many claims are denied because the insurance company questions the severity of symptoms or finds the documentation lacking. Legal representation can help address these gaps.
- The Law Office of Justin C. Frankel, P.C., has helped clients recover more than $300 million by working closely with doctors and building strong, evidence-backed claims.
More than 1.3 million Americans live with rheumatoid arthritis, but getting disability benefits isn’t always simple. Despite the significant impact of this condition on their quality of life and ability to work, many applicants face stringent requirements and lengthy waiting periods before receiving the support they need.
For New Yorkers facing these challenges, understanding your legal rights and having proper representation can make the difference between disability claim approval and denial. The intricate documentation requirements and shifting definitions of disability demand skills in navigating both medical evidence and insurance company criteria.
At the Law Office of Justin C. Frankel, P.C., we provide sound legal advice to claimants seeking disability benefits and strongly advocate for their rights against insurance companies when their claims are denied. Contact us today to schedule a free consultation.
Why Our Clients Trust the Law Office of Justin C. Frankel, P.C.
Disability claims involving inflammatory arthritis can be especially difficult. Symptoms like joint pain and limited mobility often vary from day to day, which makes proving the severity of your condition more complicated. That is why our attorneys work directly with your medical providers to show how arthritis impacts your ability to carry out daily tasks and perform your job.
We Have Won More Than $300 Million for Our Clients
We have recovered more than $300 million for clients by managing complex disability claims with care and attention to detail. Our firm offers free consultations to help you understand your options and take the next steps in pursuing benefits for your arthritis-related disability case.
Testimonials
“Highly Recommend for Disability. I am incredibly grateful to Justin Frankel and his paralegal Christina Panzarella for the outstanding support and expertise they provided throughout my disability insurance process. From the moment I reached out, Justin was attentive, professional, and genuinely invested in helping me. They walked me through every step, explained the complex legal details in a way that was easy to understand, and kept me informed at every stage. Justin understands dentistry and how a disability can effect your ability to practice. He also understands and has worked with all of the different insurance companies, and each companies nuances. Thanks to their thorough preparation, strategic approach, and understanding of the system, they were able to successfully win my appeal. I truly felt like I had a strong advocate in my corner, and I can’t imagine going through this process without their guidance. If you’re looking for a reliable and knowledgeable attorney to handle your disability claim, I highly recommend Justin Frankel.” — Heidi W.
“I would recommend the Law Office of Justin Frankel without hesitation. Atty Frankel and his senior paralegal, Christina, were amazing from beginning to end. They were consistently in touch with me and made sure I was updated and part of the disability appeal process. If you want a professional, top notch law firm fighting for your rights, I would unequivocally recommend that you call this law firm.” — Susan A.
“I have been a client of Justin Frankel for 8 years. From my very first, tearful phone call to him, Justin offered compassion and kindness. He expressed interest in my case. I was reassured by his confidence in his expertise. Justin won my disability appeal and has continued to represent me, acting as a buffer for me against the insurance company. If you are struggling with your disability claim, I strongly recommend giving Justin Frankel a call.” — Mary K.
What is Arthritis?

Arthritis is a chronic condition that causes joint inflammation and swelling, producing symptoms like pain, stiffness, and limited motion. In New York, arthritis may qualify for disability benefits through long-term disability insurance.
What Are the Different Types of Arthritis?
There are over 100 types of arthritis and related conditions, each with different causes and treatments. Some common types include:
- Osteoarthritis
- Rheumatoid arthritis
- Psoriatic arthritis
- Ankylosing spondylitis
- Reactive arthritis
- Infectious arthritis
Can Arthritis Cause Disability?
Arthritis commonly leads to disability when symptoms prevent normal work activities and daily tasks. Both osteoarthritis and rheumatoid arthritis can create substantial physical limitations that impact mobility and independence.
What Type of Rheumatoid Arthritis Symptoms Qualify for Disability?
To qualify for disability benefits, the symptoms of your rheumatoid arthritis (RA) must be severe enough to significantly limit your physical abilities and daily activities. Some of the symptoms include:
- Chronic pain and swelling across multiple joints
- Morning stiffness lasting for 30+ minutes
- Limited movement and reduced dexterity
- Severe fatigue affecting concentration
- Neurological symptoms (i.e., tingling)
- Systemic issues (i.e., weight loss)
- Physical restrictions preventing job duties
- Regular symptom flares that disrupt work
How Do I Obtain Long-Term Disability Insurance Benefits for Osteoarthritis or Rheumatoid Arthritis?
Filing for long-term disability benefits requires submitting a formal claim with your insurance company, supported by thorough medical evidence. Key documentation includes:
- Treatment records from your doctors
- X-rays and MRI results showing joint damage
- Lab tests confirming your form of arthritis
- Your physician’s report detailing work accessibility limitations
Track your symptoms daily and note the following:
- Pain levels and locations
- Mental impairments
- Medication effects
- Activity restrictions
- Flare-up frequency
Most policies define disability as the inability to perform your job initially, then any occupation after two years. You are entitled to appeal with additional evidence. Working with a disability attorney can strengthen your claim’s chances of approval.
Challenges Osteoarthritis and Rheumatoid Arthritis Disability Claimants Might Face

Arthritis disability claims often face heightened scrutiny from insurance companies due to the subjective nature of symptoms. Pain, stiffness, and mobility issues can vary day-to-day, making it challenging to document the medical treatment and prove the symptoms.
Success in obtaining benefits typically requires:
- Detailed medical records from treating physicians
- Regular evaluations by rheumatologists
- Documentation of specific work limitations
- Evidence of ongoing treatment compliance
- Clear connection between symptoms and job restrictions
Claims lacking thorough specialist documentation face a higher risk of denial. Insurance companies frequently question the severity of limitations when medical evidence is incomplete or inconsistent.
How Can a Disability Lawyer Help With My Arthritis Disability Claim in New York?
A disability lawyer provides essential guidance through long-term disability and ADA claims for arthritis patients. Your attorney can:
- Work with your rheumatologists and orthopedists to document symptoms
- Submit comprehensive medical evidence showing functional limitations
- Handle all communication with insurance companies
- File timely appeals if your claim is denied
- Present your case effectively at hearings
New York disability attorneys like the Law Office of Justin C. Frankel, P.C. understand local processes and insurance requirements. We can manage the complex paperwork while building strong evidence of how joint pain, stiffness, and mobility issues prevent you from working.
Red Flags to Avoid When Choosing a Disability Lawyer
When selecting legal representation for your arthritis disability claim, watch for these warning signs in your lawyer.
- If they make promises about winning your case or guarantee specific outcomes.
- If they have limited experience handling arthritis disability claims.
- They fail to communicate clearly about legal fees, costs, or payment structure.
- They show poor responsiveness to client inquiries or make it difficult to schedule appointments.
- They lack proper credentials or professional memberships.
- They or their firm receive negative client reviews or have a history of disciplinary actions.
- They are pressuring you to sign contracts without providing an adequate explanation.
- If they have limited knowledge about medical conditions like rheumatoid arthritis and osteoarthritis.
Being aware of these red flags can help you avoid attorneys who may mishandle your claim, misrepresent your chances of success, or fail to provide the support and transparency you need. Choosing the right legal representation is critical when navigating the complex and medically detailed process of a long-term disability claim.
Contact Our Disability Attorneys Today for a Free Consultation
Filing a disability claim for arthritis can feel overwhelming, but you don’t have to handle it alone. With the right medical documentation and experienced legal support, it’s possible to put together a solid claim that clearly shows how your condition affects your ability to work.
If you’re dealing with rheumatoid arthritis or osteoarthritis and need help getting disability benefits in New York, including New York City, we offer free case evaluations to help you.
Call our office today at 888-583-4959 or use our contact form to discuss disability insurance policies and how we can help protect your claim.
Frequently Asked Questions
Long-term disability insurance policies (sometimes referred to as LTD policies) generally follow a two-part definition of disability:
- Own occupation period (first 24 months): Unable to perform the main duties of your current job.
- Any occupation period (after 24 months): Unable to perform the duties of any job for which you’re qualified through education, training, experience, and wage requirements.
Each policy contains specific terms defining disability. Some policies require complete inability to work, while others consider partial disability. Review your policy carefully or consult an attorney to understand how disability is defined in your specific case.
Osteoarthritis becomes a qualifying disability when joint damage and symptoms prevent you from performing your essential job functions. Insurance companies assess disability based on:
- Medical imaging showing joint deterioration
- Physical limitations documented by physicians
- Impact on specific work duties
- Daily activity restrictions
- Treatment history and response
- Frequency of medical appointments
Your policy’s specific definition of disability determines the required level of impairment. Some policies require complete inability to work, while others recognize partial disability. Medical records must link your osteoarthritis symptoms to workplace limitations. Regular treatment notes from orthopedists or rheumatologists help establish the severity of your condition.
Three common reasons for long-term disability benefit ineligibility include:
- Your medical condition does not meet the insurance policy’s definition of disability. If your symptoms do not align with the policy’s criteria for total or partial disability, your claim may be denied.
- Insufficient or incomplete medical documentation. Missing records, vague physician statements, or a lack of objective evidence can weaken your claim.
- Policy exclusions that apply to your condition. Some policies exclude coverage for pre-existing conditions, mental health diagnoses, or self-reported symptoms.
Regular appointments with rheumatologists and careful documentation of symptoms help maintain eligibility. Submit all required medical records promptly to avoid benefit disruption.
If you received a denial letter after your initial application, take the following steps:
- Consider working with a disability claims attorney who can identify weaknesses in your original submission and strengthen your appeal with additional medical and legal support.
- Review the denial letter carefully to identify the specific reasons for the rejection and to note the deadline for filing an appeal.
- Request a copy of your complete claim file from the insurance company to better understand what information they used to evaluate your claim.
- Collect additional medical records that directly address the issues or gaps cited by the insurer in the denial letter.
- Ask your rheumatologist to provide detailed documentation outlining your diagnosis, symptoms, treatment plan, and specific limitations.
- Keep a written record showing how your condition prevents you from performing the core duties of your job.
- Submit your appeal within the required timeframe, which is typically 180 days from the date of the denial.
An experienced disability attorney will examine your claim file, identify gaps in documentation, and help build a compelling appeal that meets filing deadlines.